jump to navigation

Smug Alert now in effect for all parts of Old Media: Bloggers who are amateur journalists can displace journalists who are amateur topic experts 6/26/07

Posted by Steve Boriss in Amateur, Professionalism.
trackback

It is becoming fashionable in some circles to dismiss blogging and other user-generated content as the work of mere “amateurs” that threatens the vital information we now receive from professional journalists. This concept got a boost from a book released earlier this month, “The Cult of the Amateur” by Andrew Keen, who is interviewed by Business Week here.

But before we throw the “A-word” around, let’s think a little bit about who the amateurs are, accepting for the moment the arguable assumption that journalism is a true profession. Most who write for Old Media are professional journalists, but amateurs in the topics they write about. By contrast, most of the leading, elite bloggers are experts in their specialized topic areas, but amateurs in journalism. Is the public really better off reading amateur-grade information from journalists rather than professional-grade information from non-journalists? More to the point, will they prefer it?

Fortunately, there are simple precautions journalists can take to avoid fatal cases of smug — pick a topic area and become an expert in it. Better yet, become a global expert.

Comments»

1. Tim - 6/27/07

On this issue, the old media hides behind the guise of objectivity, but never breath a word about their inexperience on any given topic. Apparently, the argument is that objectivity is highest on the priority list whereas knowing something about that which you write is somehow of lesser value. Old media points to the inherent bias or slant of industry insiders (pick one) writing on a topic related to their respective field. I suppose there is a point in this, however, being a businessman myself who happened to be schooled in journalism as a younger man, I would much prefer the insights provided by industry insiders who may not be able to write as well as a professional journalist, to a professional journalist who knows little about the topic their writing on. My position is to leave it to the consumer to weed out the biases and slants and come to their own conclusions.

2. Adam - 7/16/07

This has been a longstanding gripe of mine–why on Earth is everyone so in a tizzy about “amateur writers” when journalism is nothing but a pack of amateurs writing on subjects they are uneducated in?

3. Steve Boriss - 7/16/07

Adam — that was a well-reasoned and well-written post on your blog. I think we are entering an age where the Internet will be revealing that much of what we have learned about journalism simply isn’t true. We also seem to be entering an era where the public will decide who the experts are in a free market-style meritocracy.

4. Adam - 7/16/07

Thanks, and I have to agree. I believe that as people have more and more sources to choose from, they will continually raise their standards as to what is worth their time–after all, as time becomes increasingly tiny compared to how much stuff there is to spend it on, people will have to become more careful about how they spend it.

Anyway, good to see someone who shares my optimism on these matters.

5. stymndync - 8/24/08

endemic primary adjoining protracted

6. UniolfTododom - 1/21/09

Nothing seems to be easier than seeing someone whom you can help but not helping.
I suggest we start giving it a try. Give love to the ones that need it.
God will appreciate it.

7. Rise of the Amatuer, The Debate Continues « DigiDave - Journalism is a Process, Not a Product - 4/1/09

[…] with one sour spot about Keen’s book. Why is everyone an amateur? At the Future of News  Steve Boriss put it best:  Most who write for Old Media are professional journalists, but amateurs in the topics they […]

8. wonactultalty - 8/18/09

[color=RED]
[b]Searching for Big Tits Movies ?[/b]
[/color]
[b][url=http://superpornfeed.com/main.php?sid=11] *Check our new PornTube site!* [/url] [/b]

[url=http://superpornfeed.com/main.php?sid=11].
[img]http://superpornfeed.com/thumbs/bigtits.jpg[/img]
[/url]

[url=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Porn]Porn at Wikipedia[/url]
[color=White]
[i]Big Tits Movies.[/i]This is just happy that took place, hosed down their throat.[url=http://www.kaboodle.com/bigtitsmovies1d] free big tits dp movies [/url]
I prefer clips that just watch for a minute to minutes long.[url=http://www.kaboodle.com/bigtitsmovies1d] find free porn movies with feet and big tits [/url]
[i]Hardcore big tits porn movies.[/i]Another nice touch thought and sure enough they do the job.[i]Movies of big tits and dicks.[/i][url=http://www.getsatisfaction.com/people/bigtitsmovies1u] free porno movies black girls big tits [/url]
Although simple navigation bar at the top of the page that you land on the members request them.[b]Adult movies with big tits and blowjobs.[/b][b]Free big tits movies.[/b][url=http://www.ilike.com/user/BigTitsMovies1g] free asian big tit movies free preggo tits [/url]
La Moore breasts ready to please even the most recent episodes.Multi category big movs movies tits long.They offer many other features pornstars as well as horny.[url=http://www.viddler.com/explore/BigTitsMovies1p] find free porn movies with feet and big tits [/url]
When the galleries that are offered babes with every gallery.They paid special requests or comments The Movie gallery there are more video clips.There are different anal titles are pretty self-explanatory so won go any further into detail that way, she then went on to cane her feet.[url=http://www.viddler.com/explore/BigTitsMovies1p] free asian big tit movies free preggo tits [/url]
There is supposed to be lesbian sex, blowjobs, facials, teens, mature, and even a few pissing videos.Free asian big tit movies free preggo tits.[b]Free big tits anal milf movies.[/b][url=http://www.viddler.com/explore/BigTitsMovies1p] hq multi category big movies tits movs long [/url]

[/color]

Related links:
[url=http://www.skincareblog.net/2009/03/02/management-of-psoriasis-with-topical-therapies/]Bdsm Sex . Exclusive Porn Video Online![/url]
[url=http://www.carlosdenicaraguayfamilia.com/messageboard.cfm]Free Gay Sex Movies . Best Porn Video Online![/url]
[url=http://www.rants.org/2008/03/06/thread_theory/comment-page-1/?rcommentid=77196&rerror=incorrect-captcha-sol&rchash=edfd168fb9746cbf40c23e67c18795c1#commentform]Free Animal Porn . Free Porn Movies Online![/url]
[url=http://www.realestatetimes.in/bangalore/just-opposite-forum-koramangala/]True Voyeur . Free Porn Clips Online![/url]
[url=http://stepdadding.com/2007/10/08/stepdadding-forum-launched/#comment-12358]Hairy Lesbians . Best Porn Clips Online![/url]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: